So who's really to blame on the
M/V Princess of the Star tragedy? PAGASA? Bad Weather? the Coast guard?
Let me just recount on the performance of Sulpicio Lines, Inc. over the past decade. Since the most tragic 1987 M/V Doña Paz sinking, Sulpicio has sank 4 of its big ships and ferries, the latest of which is the M/V Princess of the Stars. Talk about performance in the field of marine navigation. And of the four tragedies that the company has figured in, they were never sacked, nor temporarily closed down, nor given reprimand.
See the top water-related tragedies at peace-time. M/v Princess of the Orient was not on the list, but I think this was also a Sulpicio Lines-owned vessel that sank off the coast of Batangas, leaving about 150 dead and hundreds more injured.
Courtesy of
http://www.wikipedia.com/:
4,300–4,500 - MV Doña Paz (Philippines, 1987)
2,750–3,920 -
SS Kiangya (off
Shanghai, 1948)
1,863 -
MV Joola (
Senegal, 2002)
1,547 -
Sultana (
Mississippi River, 1865)
1,517 -
RMS Titanic (
North Atlantic, 1912)
1,155 -
Toya Maru (
Tsugaru Strait, 1954)
1,021 -
SS General Slocum (
New York, 1904)
1,018 -
MV al-Salam Boccaccio 98 (
Red Sea, 2006)
1,012 -
RMS Empress of Ireland, (
Saint Lawrence River, 1914)
c.1,000 -
SS Hong Moh (
South China Sea, 1921)
894 -
MV Bukova (
Lake Victoria,
Tanzania, 1996)
852 -
MS Estonia (
Baltic Sea, 1994)
835 -
SS Eastland (
Chicago, 1915)
800 - MV Princess of Stars capsized by Typhoon Fengshen off Sibuyan Island, Philippines, June 21, 2008.
737 -
SS Camorta (
Irrawaddy Delta, 1902)
c.640 -
SS Princess Alice and SS Bywell Castle (
River Thames, 1878)
627 -
SS Norge (
Rockall, 1904)
625 -
SS Ramdas (
Bombay, 1947)
608 -
Novorossiysk (
Sevastopol, 1955)
600 -
Shamia (
Meghna River, southern
Barisa,
Bangladesh, May 1986)
587 -
ErtuÄŸrul (off
Kushimoto,
Japan, 1890)
580 -
Indonesian passenger ship
Tamponas 2 (caught fire and sank in
Java Sea, January 1981)
558 -
SS Principe de Asturias (off Brazil, 1916)
550 -
Cahaya Bahari (off
Sulawesi,
Indonesia, 2000)
546 -
RMS Atlantic (
Nova Scotia, 1873)
528 -
MV Nazreen 1 (
Chandpur, Bangladesh, July 2003)
500 -
Atlas Star (
Dhaleswar River,
Munshiganj, Bangladesh, 1986)
497 -
Ebisu Maru (off
Tokushima,
Japan, 1946)
464 -
Salem Express (off
Safaga,
Egypt, 1991)
461 -
MV Senopati Nusantara (off
Mandalika Island,
Indonesia, 2006)
438 -
Baccha Singh (
Manihari Ghat,
Bihar,
River Ganges,
6 August 1988)
423 -
Admiral Nakhimov (
Black Sea, 1986)
400 -
Reina Regenta (off
Gibraltar,
March 11,
1895)
400 -
SS Lady Elgin (
Chicago, 1860)
400 -
Cataraqui (
King Island, Australia, 1865)
397 -
Toyo Maru 10 (near
Kurushima,
Japan, 1945)
392 -
SS Himera (off
Athens,
Greece,
January 19,
1947)
361 -
KM Bismas Raya 2 (off
Merauke,
Irian Jaya,
Indonesia, October 1999)
358 -
HMS Victoria (near
Tripoli, Lebanon, 1893)
357 -
10th of Ramadan (
Lake Nasser,
Egypt, 1983)
353 -
SIEV-X (off Indonesia, 2001)
340 -
MV Shalahuddin 2 (
Meghna River,
Bangladesh, 2002)
338 -
Gurita (off
Sabang,
Aceh,
Indonesia, January 1996)
325 -
Harta Limba (off
Kalimantan,
Indonesia, 1999)
314 -
Principessa Matalda (off
Porto Seguro,
Bahia,
Brazil,
October 25,
1927)
308 -
Namyong-Ho (
Korean Strait, 1970)
304 - Japanese passenger boat
Sekirei Maru capsized with crush by windy condition off northwestern Awaji Island, Japan,
December 9,
1945.
300 -
Brazilian river boat
Sobral Santos capsized
Amazon River,
Obidos, Brazil,
September 20,
1981300 -
Turkish ferry Üsküdar capsized and sank at
Bay of İzmit,
Kocaeli,
Turkey,
March 1,
1958297 -
RMS Tayleur, (
Lambay,
Ireland, 1854)
292 - A Seohae,
South Korean ferry, West Sea, overloaded with 362 people, capsized off Puan county
October 10,
1993[6]288 -
SS Heraklion (
Souda,
Crete,
Greece, 1966)
280 -
Chinese ferry
Dashun caught fire and capsized in rough seas off
Yellow Sea,
Yantai,
Shandong,
China,
November 24,
1999280 -
Nigerian passenger boat capsized at
Ibaka,
Akwa Ibom,
Nigeria, April 1998
280 - Myanmarese passenger ferry
U Hla Myist sank by collided with Japanese vassel
Bombei Maru at
Yangon Bay,
Myanmar, February 1973
279 -
Filipino floating pagoda capsized in
Bocaue river, northern
Manila,
Philippines,
July 2,
1993272 -
Kenyan ferry
MV Mtongwe sank at
Mtongwe,
Mombasa,
Kenya, 1994
260 -
USS Maine (
Havana,
Cuba, 1898) it is disputed whether this was accidental or an act of terrorism
260 -
Earl of Abergavenny (off
Portland Bill, 1805)
260 -
Nuestra Señora de Atocha (
Florida Keys, 1622)
259 -
Portuguese passenger ship
Save ran aground off
Mozambique,
July 8,
1961250+ -
Great Lakes Storm of 1913 (
Great Lakes Basin, 1913)
250 - Filipino ferry Dona Marylin capsized by Typhoon Ruby off Maripipi Island, Philippines, October, 1988
250 - Bangladeshi ferry
MV Dinar gone down in strong whirlpool at Meghna River,
Chandpul, Bangladesh,
August 20,
1994249 -
Chang Tyong-Ho (
Busan,
South Korea, 1953)
230 - Brazilian double-decker boat
Novo Amapo capsized
Belem de Cajari,
Macapa,
Amazon River, Brazil, 1981
230 - Bangladeshi ferry
Rushi capsized by stormy condition at Padma River, Bangladesh, April 1980
226 -
Ville du Havre (North Atlantic, 1873)
220 - Nigerian passenger boat capsized by stormy sea off
Uyo,
Akwa Ibom, Nigeria,
January 24,
1996215 - Myanmarese double-decker ferry sank during storm at
Gyaing River, 1990
210 - Illegal African immigrants boat sank off
Sfax,
Tunisia, 2003
209 - Seven Japanese fishing boat sank by Super typhoon Carmen (off
Agrihan, 1965)
206 -
Egyptian ferry boat
Adel capsized at
Upper Nile,
Maghagha,
Governorate, Egypt, May, 1963
205 -
HMS Iolaire (off
Stornoway, 1919)
200 -
SS Victoria (
London, Ontario, 1881)
200 - Indonesian passenger ferry
KMP Digul capsized in rough sea off
Merakuke,
Papua,
Indonesia, July 2005.
200 - Bangladeshi passenger ferry
Haisal rammed by collide with cargo vessel at Dhaleswari river, Bangladesh, December, 1988.
193 -
Herald of Free Enterprise (
English Channel, 1987)
192 - Two illegal immigrants boats sank off
Gulf of Aden,
Yemen, 2007
189 -
MV Maharaj (
Buriganga River,
Bangladesh, 2005)
189 -
HMS Orpheus, (
Auckland, 1863)
185 -
Batavia (off
Australia, 1629) includes both drowned and murdered
182 -
Congo ferry
Dieu Merci capsized at
Mai-Ndombe Lake,
Bandunu,
Democratic Republic of Congo,
November 27,
2003.
180 -
Somali refugee boat capsized off
Gulf of Aden,
Yemen,
March 31,
1998177 -
Russian cruise ship
Alexander Suvorov crashed into a railroad bridge at
Volga River,
Ulyanovsk, southwestern
Russia,
June 5,
1983.
171 - Chinese sightseeing boat sank at
Songhua River,
Harbin,
Heilongjiang,
China, August 1985
170 -
Staffordshire (
Cape Sable,
1853)
168 -
Shiun Maru (
Takamatsu, Japan, 1955)
167 - Japanese ferry
Nankai Maru capsized off southern
Awaji Island,
Japan,
January 26,
1958167 -
Dona Cassandra sank by typhoon Orchid (off Mindanao, 1983)
165 -
Tamil refugees boat capsized off
Nanchchikuddah,
Sri Lanka,
February 20,
1997161 -
Romanian passenger boat
Mogosoaia sank by collide with
Bulgarian barge
Pita Karamonchev at
Danube River,
Galatzi,
Romania,
September 10,
1989158 -
Scandinavian Star (
Skagerrak, 1990)
158 - Sierra Leone boat Amunafa capsized off coast
Bailor,
Sierra Leone,
August 3,
2007150 -
Peruvian ferry
La Chachita capsized at
Maranon River, central
Peru,
May 7,
1991.
150 - Overloaded motorrized canoe capsized off
Tasso,
Sierra Leone,
March 25,
1999.
150 - A pontoon ferry sink by overturned on
Shire River,
Malawi,
May 23,
1965150 -
Colombian excursion ship
Vencedor capsized off
Buenaventura,
Valle del Cauca, Colombia, September, 1961
148 -
Medusa (off
Senegal, 1816)
147 -
Chinese passenger ferry capsized at
Shanshui,
Guangdong, China on
March 2,
1983140 -
SS Koombana (off
Port Hedland, Western Australia, 1912)
140 -
Danish passenger ship
Kjoebenhavn capsized after striking mine off coast of
Jutland,
Denmark, June, 1948
140 -
Italian ferry
Moby Prince collide with oil tanker, dense fog off
Livorno,
Tuscan,
Italy, 1991
140 - Two African immigrants boat sank off
Seferihisar,
Turkey, 2007
134 -
SS Morro Castle (off
Asbury Park, New Jersey, 1934)
134 - Peruvian passenger boat
Adresito capsized at
Amazon River,
Iquitos,
Loreto Maynas,
Peru,
March 6,
1990.
131 - Chinese passenger boat
Rong Jian capsized at
Hejiang River,
Rongshan,
Sichuan,
China, June 2000.
131 -
Tararua (off
Waipapa Point, New Zealand, 1881)
130 -
Princess Victoria (
Scottland, 1953)
130 - Nigerian ferry
Olodiama collided with a tugboat off
Port Harcourt,
Rivers State, Nigeria, September, 1997
130 -
Thai ferry boat
Sathit collided with chemical tanker at
Gulf of Thailand,
Si Racha, Thailand, March 1992
129 -
USS Thresher (N. Atlantic, 1963)
128 -
HMS Gladiator (
Isle of Wight, 1908)
128 - Greek cruise ship
Lakonia sunk after fire on board off
Madeira,
Portugal,
December 28,
1962.
124+ -
SS Yongala (
Townsville, Australia, 1911)
124 -
Djibouti ferry
Al Baraqua 2 capsized off
Tadjoura,
Djibouti,
April 6,
2006120 -
Ghanan motorboat capsized at
Lake Volta,
Jasikan,
Ghana,
April 10,
2006.
118 -
Kursk (
Barents Sea, 2000)
117 -
Kinka Maru (
Onagawa, northeastern
Miyagi, Japan, 1946)
113 - Japanese wooden passenger boat
Kitagawa Maru 5 capsized at
Onomichi,
Japan, April 1957.
102 -
SS Gothenburg. (
Great Barrier Reef,
Queensland,
24 February 1875).
100 - Brazilian cruise boat
Bateau Mouche capsized at
Copacabana beach,
Guanabara Bay,
Rio de Janeiro, Brazil,
January 1,
1989.
99 -
USS Scorpion (near
Azores, 1968)
92 - Japanese passenger boat
Koun Maru sank by rough sea off
Misumi,
Amakusa, western
Kyūshū, Japan,
October 1,
1933.
85 - Illegal African immigrants boat sank
Mareg,
Puntland,
Yemen, 2003
82 -
STV Royston Grange (off
Montevideo, Uruguay, 1972)
81 -
Samina (near
Paros,
Greece,
2000)
80 -
Pamir (1957)
80 - Hong Kong ferry Fatshan plunged by torrential typhoon Rose, Auguat 17, 1971.
78 - Greek tanker
Spyros exploded at Jorong shipyard,
Singapore,
October 12,
197870 -
Ming 361 (2003)
58 -
Bahrain wooden plesure boat
al-Dana capsized off
Gulf of Bahrain, 2006
57 -
Danish passenger boat
Turisten Killing 57 pass. after fire on board on Haderslev Dam,
July 8,
195954 -
MS Jan Heweliusz (
Baltic Sea,
1993)
53 -
TEV Wahine (
Wellington, NZ, 1968)
51 -
SS Andrea Doria (off
Nantucket, Mass. 1956)
48 - Brazilian river boat Comandante Sales capsized at
Solimoes River, on the outskirts of
Manacapura,
Amazonas,
Brazil,
May 4,
2008.
45 -
SS Elingamite (
Three Kings Islands, NZ, 1902)
44 -
British bulk carrier
Derbyshire capsized by structual failure and
Typhoon Orchid off
Ryukyu Island,
September 9,
198036 -
FV Gaul (
Barents Sea, 1974)
35 -
HMS Pandora (
Torres Strait,
1791)
31 -
SS Carnatic (
Red Sea, 1869)
29 -
SS Edmund Fitzgerald (
Lake Superior, 1975)
28 -
Soviet submarine K-19 (to fire,
24 February 1972)
20 -
Ethan Allen (
Lake George (New York),
2 October 2005)
17 -
1979 Fastnet race (
Fastnet Rock, 1979)
16 -
MS Sleipner (
Norway, 1999)
13 -
Essex (South Pacific, 1819)
So who's really to blame on the tragedy? There were talks of engine trouble. There were news of holes in the ship. There were news about cargo loading in a passenger vessel. And Sulpicio Lines is blaming everything to bad weather forecasting.
My heart bleeds for the families of more than 700 missing bodies still underneath the sank M/V Princess of the Stars. I pray that justice be served.